Peanut Butter Cookies

Though I didn’t eat many Nutter Butters growing up, I would always find myself infatuated with the perfectly-shaped, crisp, nutty cookie sandwiches when I did have them on rare occasion. I was so intrigued by this recipe, I wanted to make them as soon as possible, because they just looked that good.

In my attempt of making some of my own, a few things went wrong. Besides the usual mess in the kitchen, I realized I didn’t have enough all-purpose flour, accidentally put only half the amount of butter called for in the recipe, and on top of that, I made the dough balls way too large to put any kind of filling in the middle to eat the supposed “cookie sandwich” properly. Ha!

 I solved the flour issue by mixing all-purpose flour with cake flour, which is finer in texture. And in regards to the butter, I let it slide just to see how to cookies would turn out. Thankfully, I didn’t end up seeing or tasting any issues and they turned out into crisp, but still chewy, peanut butter cookies shaped into cute peanuts. Though I still want to give the Nutter Butters recipe a second go, this altered recipe will be a keeper. Sometimes baking experiments can turn into wonderful creations!

Welcome to The Bella Insider! Here you'll find advice, inspiration, and favorite finds for the college student, new graduate, or young working professional who's seeking to build a life using their unique talents & skills.

Read Next

Shop #TheBellaInsiderHome

Leave a Comment